Ðóñ Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 2053,   Articles in work: 307 Declined articles: 852 
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Dina Kirnarskaya Musical prodigies: «fakes» and «realities»

Published in journal "Scientific notes of the Gnesins' Russian Academy of Music", 2014-3 , pages 55-73.

Resume: Musical prodigies as a phenomenon are known during several centuries while children appearing on concert stage are being used as a commercial product. There exists a supposition that such exploitation since early age could be the reason for their «burning out» when their talent fades away leading to various psychological traumas. The author argues that although such views are basically convincing it’s possible to offer another hypothesis based on psychological similarity of prodigies and so called «idiots-savants», autistic children and teenagers with extraordinary abilities. The author is offering various arguments to support her idea: according to the paper’s discourse «burned out» prodigies who failed to develop into outstanding musicians could share with idiots-savants autistic predisposition based on communication deficiencies connected in the to expressive ear for music. Expressive ear can be considered «communication centre» of musical talent referring to non-notational features of music.

Keywords: wunderkind, absolute pitch, savant, autism, expressive ear for music.

This article can be downloaded freely in PDF format for reading. Download article

1. Asaf'ev B.V. Slukh Glinki // Izbrannye trudy. T. I. M.: Izd-vo Akademii nauk SSSR, 1952.
2. Barinova M.N. Vospominaniya o Gofmane i Buzoni. M.: Muzyka, 1964.
3. Debyussi K. Stat'i. Retsenzii. Besedy. M.—L.: Muzyka, 1964.
4. Meyer K. Shostakovich: Zhizn', tvorchestvo, vremya. SPb.: Kompozitor, 1998.
5. Mil'shteyn Ya.I. Ferents List. M.: Muzyka, 1999.
6. Rubinshteyn A.G. Avtobiograficheskie vospominaniya A.G. Rubinshteyna 1829—1889 gg.
SPb.: Redaktsiya zhurnala «Russkaya starina», [b. g.].
7. Teplov B.M. Psikhologiya i psikhofiziologiya individual'nykh razlichiy. M.: Izd-vo
«Institut prakticheskoy psikhologii»; Voronezh: NPO «MODEK», 1998.
8. Bryben C. Anatomy of genius. Clynsdale: Brixton, 1938.
9. Chandler S., Christie P., Newson E., Prevezer W. Developing a diagnostic and intervention
package for 2- to 3-year-olds with autism: Outcomes of the Frameworks for Communication approach
// Autism. Vol. 6 (2002). P. 47—69.
10. Dorian J.-P. Un violon parle. Souvenirs de Jacques Thibaud. Paris: del Duca-Paris, 1953.
11. Gaede S.E., Parsons O.A., Bertera J.H. Hemispheric differences in music perception: aptitude
vs. experience // Neuropsychologia. Vol. 16 (1978). P. 369—373.
12. Hallam S. The predictors of achievement and dropout in instrumental tuition // Psychology
of Music. Vol. 26(2) (1998). P. 116—132.
13. Hassler M. Maturation rate and spatial, verbal, and musical abilities: A seven-year-longitudinal
study // International Journal of Neuroscience. Vol. 58 (1991). P. 183—198.
14. Heaton P., Hermelin B., Pring L. Autism and pitch processing: A precursor for savant musical
ability // Music Perception. Vol. 15 (1998). P. 291—305.
15. Heaton P., Hermelin B., Pring L. Can children with autistic spectrum disorders perceive affect
in music? An experimental investigation // Psychological Medicine. Vol. 29 (1999). P. 1405—1410.
16. Heaton P., Pring L., Hermelin B. A pseudo-savant: A case of exceptional musical splinter
skills // Neurocase: The Neural Basis of Cognition. Vol. 5(6) (1999). P. 503—509.
17. Sacks O. Musical ability // Science. Vol. 268 (1995). P. 621—622.
18. Scheerer M., Rothmann E., Goldstein K. A Case of «idiot savant»: An experimental study
of personality organization // Psychological Monographs. Vol. 58 (4) (1945). P. 1—63.
19. Scripp L., Davidson L. Giftedness and professional training: The impact of music reading
skills on musical development of conservatory students // Beyond Terman: Contemporary longitudinal
studies of giftedness and talent / Ed. by Subotnik R.F., Arnold K.D. et al. Norwood, NJ,
USA: Ablex Publishing Corp., 1994. P. 186—211.
20. Simonton D.K. Creative development as acquired expertise: Theoretical issues and an empirical
test // Developmental Review Vol. 20 (2000). P. 283—318.
21. Wilson B.A., Baddeley A.D., Kapur N. Dense amnesia in a professional musician following
herpes simplex virus encephalitis // Journal of Clinical & Experimental Neuropsychology. Vol. 17
(1995). P. 668—681.
22. Winner E. Gifted children: Myths And Realities. NY: Basic Books, 1997.
23. Young R.L., Nettelbeck T. The abilities of a musical savant and his family // Journal
of Autism & Developmental Disorders. Vol. 25 (1995). P. 231—248.

Correct link to this article:
just copy this link to clipboard