Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 2075,   Articles in work: 306 Declined articles: 850 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

The Taxation Avoidance Prenvetive Regime in Russia at Late XIXth - Early XXth Century
Rakov Il'ya Andreevich

lecturer of the Department of Financial Law at Ural State Law University

620034, Russia, Sverdlov Region, Yekaterinburg, Kolmogorov's str., 54

attorneyscase@gmail.com

 

 

Abstract.

In his research Rakov analyzes the problem of tax avoidance from the point of view of the tax shifting concept from the historical point of view. The subject of the research is the terms 'tax shifting' and 'tax avoidance'. The scope of the research also covers tax avoidance patterns, classifications of tax avoidance, and tax avoidance preventive measures. Within the framework of the research the author views the tax avoidance process as an economic and legal phenomenon. The author examines the grounds for the creation of the tax avoidance preventive regime with regard to the Russian environment of the late XIXth - early XXth centuries. In the course of writing this article Rakov has applied historical method, comparative law, formal law methods, formal law, hermeneutics, synergetics, inductive and modelling research methods. The comparative analysis of the Russian and Western European approaches to the tax avoidance issue at the turn of the XIXth - XXth centuries has demonstrated that the development of a special legal order of tax avoidance relations had never been raised during that period. At the same time, when discussing the  nature of such relations, researchers made particular conclusions that would be later used to develop the tax avoidance concept. Based on the analysis of particular theses discussed by financial law researchers, the author of the article makes and discusses general provisions of the tax shifting concept and the grounds for the creation of the tax avoidance concept typical for the XIXth - XXth century period. 

Keywords: history of taxation, tax burden, tax shifting concept, legal avoidance, financial law doctrine, taxation scheme, taxation, tax law, financial law, avoidance patterns

DOI:

10.7256/2454-065X.2018.11.20922

Article was received:

31-10-2016


Review date:

31-10-2016


Publish date:

09-01-2019


This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Alekseenko M.M. Vzglyad na razvitie ucheniya o naloge u ekonomistov A. Smita, Zh. B. Seya, Rikardo, Simondi, i D. S. Millya. Khar'kov: Universitetskaya tipografiya, 1870. 152 s.
2.
Alekseenko M.M. Deistvuyushchee zakonodatel'stvo o pryamykh nalogakh. SPb.: Tipografiya M. Stasyulevicha, 1879. 260 s.
3.
Bezobrazov V.P. Gosudarstvennye dokhody: Teoreticheskie i prakticheskie issledovaniya. Chast' 2. Gosudarstvennye dokhody Rossii, ikh kvalifikatsiya. Nyneshnee sostoyanie i dvizhenie (1866-1872). SPb: Tipografiya V. Bezobrazova, 1872. 498 s.
4.
Brzheskii N. Gosudarstvennye dolgi Rossii: Istoriko-statisticheskie issledovaniya. SPb.: Tipo-lit. A.M. Vol'fa, 1884. 369 s.
5.
Grimm D. Ocherki po ucheniyu ob obogashchenii. Vyp. 1. Derpt, 1891. 106 s.
6.
Grimm D. Ocherki po ucheniyu ob obogashchenii. Vyp 2. Derpt, 1891. 118 s.
7.
Grimm D. Ocherki po ucheniyu ob obogashchenii. Vyp 3. Derpt, 1893. 212 s.
8.
Lassal' F. Kosvennye nalogi i polozhenie rabochego klassa // Lassal' F. Soch. M., b.g. T. 1, 1863. 132 s.
9.
Ozerov I. Kh. Osnovy finansovoi nauki: Byudzhet. Formy vzymaniya. Mestnye finansy. Gosudarstvennyi kredit. M.: YurInfoR-Press, 2008. 622 s.
10.
Terner F.G. Svedeniya o pozemel'nom naloge v inostrannykh gosudarstvakh: Materialy.-SPb.: Komissiya dlya uluchsheniya sistemy podatei i poshlin, 1860. 266 s.
11.
Terskii N.S. Piteinye sbory i aktsiznaya sistema v Rossii: Istoricheskii ocherk i nastoyashchee polozhenie. Opyt sravnitel'nogo issledovaniya glavneishikh rezul'tatov aktsiznoi sistemy i ee znacheniya dlya gosudarstva, kazny i naseleniya SPb.: Tip. V. Kirshbauma, 1890. 272 s.
12.
Yarotskii V.G. Finansovoe pravo: Lektsii, chitannye v Voenno-Yuridicheskoi Akademii. SPb: Tipo-Litografiya A.M. Stankevicha, 1898. 363 s.
13.
Wagner A. Finanzwissenschaft. 3 Aufl. 1883. Th. 1. S. 7.
14.
Pushkareva V.M. Istoriya finansovoi mysli i politiki nalogov // Finansy i statistika. 2001. 6. S. 147.
15.
Sokolov A.A. Teoriya nalogov. M.: YurInfoR-Press, 2003. C. 355.
16.
Yanzhul I.I. Osnovnye nachala finansovoi nauki. Uchenie o gosudarstvennykh dokhodakh: Izd. 4-e. SPb, 1904. S. 279.
17.
Ilovaiskii S.I. Kosvennoe oblozhenie v teorii i praktike. Odessa: Tip. Sht. voisk Odes. voen. okr., 1892. S. 304.
18.
Lappo-Danilevskii A.S. Organizatsiya pryamogo oblozheniya v moskovskom gosudarstve so vremen smuty do epokhi preobrazovanii. SPb: Tipografiya I. N. Skorokhodova, 1890. S. 69.
19.
Pushkareva V.M. Istoriya finansovoi mysli i politiki nalogov // Finansy i statistika. 2001. 6. S. 164.