Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 2000,   Articles in work: 345 Declined articles: 795 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

Reasonable doubts: standard of evidence in the international criminal courts
Romanov Roman Vladimirovich

Post-graduate student, the department of Constitutional and International Law, University of Management “TISBI”

420012, Russia, the Republic of Tatarstan, Kazan, Mushtari Street 13

r2_v@mail.ru

 

 

Abstract.

This article is dedicated to the analysis of the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard of evidence, as well as practice of its implementation by the institution of international criminal justice. The author present a historical overview of the stages of application of the aforementioned standard of evidence in international criminal courts and tribunals. The article raises a question on the ambiguity of the criteria, according to which a facts is considered proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and moreover, such ambiguity is present not only in the area of international law, but also national law of the states of Anglo-Saxon model of criminal procedure. The author examines the court rulings of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia. The conclusion is made that the implementation of the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard within the international criminal procedure requires a precise determination of its content, including formalization of the procedure and evidence in the rules of international courts and tribunals, as well as minimal list of elements which must be established by the court.

Keywords: reasonable doubt, ICTY, international criminal tribunals, international criminal tribunals, international criminal procedural law, international criminal justice, standards of evidence, beyond a reasonable doubt, international criminal procedure, proof of guilt

DOI:

10.7256/2306-9899.2016.4.21141

Article was received:

22-11-2016


Review date:

21-11-2016


Publish date:

16-01-2017


This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Mezyaev A.B. Zashchita prav obvinyaemykh v sovremennom mezhdunarodnom ugolovnom prave: Aktual'nye voprosy teorii i praktiki/ Kazan': NOU VPO "Akad. uprav. "TISBI", 2014. 396 s.
2.
Pravila protsedury i dokazyvaniya Mezhdunarodnogo tribunala po byvshei Yugoslavii. IT/32/Rev.50 // Ofitsial'nyi sait Mezhdunarodnogo tribunala po byvshei Yugoslavii v Internete.[elektronnyi resurs] URL: http://www.icty.org/x/file/Legal%20Library/Rules_procedure_evidence/IT032Rev50_en.pdf Poslednee poseshchenie 12.11.2016
3.
Elies van Sliedregt, Sergey Vasiliev Pluralism in International Criminal Law. Oxford, 2014. 411 p.
4.
The Prosecutor of the Tribunal against Slobodan Milošević (IT-02-54), The Prosecutor v. Laurent Gbagbo and Charles Blé Goudé (ICC-02/11-01/15), The Prosecutor v. Charles Ghankay Taylor (Case SCSL-2003-01-I), Prosecutor v. Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir, ICC02/05-01/09
5.
Armatta J. Twilight of Impunity: The War Crimes Trial of Slobodan Milosevic // Duke University Press. 2010. P. 2
6.
Rohan C.M. Reasonable Doubt Standard of Proof in International Criminal Trials // Principles of Evidence in International Criminal Justice, 2010; Edited by Karim A. A. Khan, Caroline Buisman, Christopher Gosnell, Oxford, 2010. P. 653-655
7.
Lezhe R. Velikie pravovye sistemy sovremennosti. Sravnitel'no-pravovoi podkhod 3 izdanie M.: Volters Kluver, 2010. S. 448
8.
United States of America v. Alstötter et al. ("The Justice Case") 3 T.W.C. 1 (1948), 6 L.R.T.W.C. 1 (1948), 14 Ann. Dig. 278 (1948) //http://law2.umkc.edu [elektronnyi resurs] URL: http://law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/nuremberg/alstoetter.htm#U.S.A.%20v.%20ALSTOETTER%20ET%20AL%20%28The%20Justice%20Cases%29: Poslednee poseshchenie 13.11.2016
9.
Budylin S.L. Delo ob ubitom pravosudii, ili Otvechaet li sud'ya za prestupleniya rezhima? // Zakon.ru, 22.03.2016 20:15/[elektronnyi resurs] URL: https://zakon.ru/blog/2016/3/22/delo_o_kriminalnoj_yusticii_ili_otvechaet_li_sudya_za_prestupleniya_rezhima, Poslednee poseshchenie 09.10.2016
10.
United States v. Altstoetter et al., Opinion and Judgment and Sentence, Green Series, Vol. 3 at 954 (Mil. Trib. No. 31947-12-04) P. 1018, 1158 // www.worldcourts.com [elektronnyi resurs] URL: http://www.worldcourts.com/imt/eng/decisions/1947.12.04_United_States_v_Altstoetter.pdf Poslednee poseshchenie 13.11.2016
11.
Prosecutor v. Delalis, et. al., Judgement, IT-96-21-T, 16 November 1998, ("Celebisi Trial Judgement") para. 599-601.
12.
Ahmed v The State (1999), Igbinovia v State (1981)
13.
Miller v. Minister of Pensions [1947] 1 All England Law Reports 372, 373-4
14.
Green v. R. (1972) 46 Australian Law Journal Reports 545
15.
Spencer M., Spencer J. Q & A Revision Guide Evidence 2013 and 2014 8 edition. Oxford, 2013. P. 17
16.
Shapiro, Barbara J. Beyond Reasonable Doubt and Probable Cause. Historical Perspectives on the Anglo-American Law of Evidence. London, 1991. P. 10-11
17.
Regina vs. Abdul Majid [2009] England and Wales Court of Appeal: Criminal 2563
18.
Keane A., McKeown P. The Modern Law of Evidence 11 edition. Oxford, 2016. P. 114
19.
Budylin S.L. Vnutrennee ubezhdenie ili balans veroyatnostei? Standarty dokazyvaniya v Rossii i za rubezhom, "Vestnik Vysshego Arbitrazhnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii", 2014, N 3, 4// EPS Sistema GARANT
20.
Whitman, James Q. "The Origins of "Reasonable Doubt: Theological Roots of the Criminal Trial"// Yale University Press. 2008. P. 3, 117
21.
Mezyaev A.B. Zashchita prav obvinyaemykh v sovremennom mezhdunarodnom ugolovnom prave: Aktual'nye voprosy teorii i praktiki. Kazan': NOU VPO "Akad. uprav. "TISBI", 2014. S. 312-313
22.
Prosecutor V. Ante Gotovina, Ivan Čermak, Mladen Markač, Judgement volume I OF II, IT-06-90-T, 14 April 2011, para. 14
23.
Prosecutor V. Ante Gotovina, Ivan Čermak, Mladen Markač, Judgement volume II OF II, IT-06-90-T, 14 April 2011, para. 1721, 1722
24.
Prosecutor V. Ante Gotovina, Mladen Markač, Judgement, IT-06-90-T, 12 November 2012, para. 83
25.
Mezyaev A.B. Vpervye v istorii etnicheskaya chistka poluchila opravdanie Mezhdunarodnogo tribunala! // http://www.fondsk.ru/, 17.11.2012 / [elektronnyi resurs] URL: http://www.fondsk.ru/news/2012/11/17/vpervye-v-istorii-etnicheskaja-chistka-poluchila-opravdanie-mezhdunarodnogo-tribunala-17702.html Poslednee poseshchenie 12.11.2016
26.
Criminal Justice Act 1967 Chapter 80 // Ofitsial'nyi sait Natsional'nogo arkhiva Velikobritanii v Internete. [elektronnyi resurs] URL:
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1967/80/pdfs/ukpga_19670080_en.pdf Poslednee poseshchenie 15.11.2016
27.
Trial Juries: Size and Verdict Rules // Official website State Court Organization [elektronnyi resurs] URL:
URL:http://data.ncsc.org/QvAJAXZfc/opendoc.htm?document=Public%20App/SCO.qvw&host=QVS@qlikviewisa&anonymous=true Poslednee poseshchenie 13.11.2016