Рус Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 2160,   Articles in work: 281 Declined articles: 942 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

Evolution and establishment of judicial administration in Soviet Russia (1917-1922)
Abdulin Robert Semenovich

PhD in Pedagogy

associate professor of the Department of Criminal Law and Process at Kurgan State University, resigned judge of the Kurgan Regional Court, honored lawer of the Russian Federation. 

640000, Russia, Kurganskaya oblast', g. Kurgan, ul. Pushkina, 187

abrosem@yandex.ru
Abstract. The subject of this research is the stage of organization of the Soviet courts, formation and evolution of the Soviet judicial administration, which had attracted and continues to attract the attention of many scholars. There has been written fairly large amount of articles, books, monographs, and theses dedicated to the events of this time, which ended with the establishment of both, the new political and new judicial systems. However, the official ideology and practice of the Soviet state construction that initially rejected the idea of separation of powers as alien and bourgeois, due to which the court throughout the entire Soviet period did not receive the true independence, left a mark upon all social phenomena, including science to a certain extent. Therefore, multiple works in the area of examination of the establishment of Soviet judicial system and judicial administration, were ideologically tendentious, referred to the extensive circle of communist and propagandistic literature, as well as accessible to public archive materials that favorably characterized the Soviet structure. The author introduces the original point of view on the complicated process of destruction of the old imperial judicial system and creation of the drastically new judicial apparatus alongside the apparatus of judicial administration until the Judiciary Reform of 1922. The scientific novelty consists in the fact that through the prism of state policy in the context of transformations, realized by the Soviet government in judicial sphere, the article demonstrates the establishment of the judicial administration. Based on the generalization of the existing research and published, but not introduced into the scientific discourse archive sources, the work formulates and substantiates the origins, political legal nature of judicial administration applicable to a particular stage of the political legal development of Russia (1917-1922).
Keywords: egal community, provisional government, Tribunal, Russia, Soviet, judicial administration, judicial system, Russian Empire, revolutionary power, October Revolution
DOI: 10.25136/2409-868X.2017.9.22622
Article was received: 12-04-2017

Review date: 08-04-2017

Publish date: 19-09-2017

This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here.

References
1.
Abdulin R.S. Sud, sudoustroistvo, pravosudie i sudebnoe upravlenie v Rossii v period s fevralya po oktyabr' 1917g.// Problemy pravoprimeneniya v sovremennoi Rossii: materialy nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii.Omsk.2015.S.160-179.
2.
Rossiiskoe zakonodatel'stvo X–XX vekov. T. 9 / pod red. O.I. Chistyakova. M.: Yurid. lit., 1994. 352 s.
3.
Konstitutsionnye proekty Vremennogo pravitel'stva //Vestnik prava. 1917. №20. S.412-413.
4.
Politicheskie partii v Rossii: stranitsy istorii / sost. A.P. Zinov'ev. M.: In-t molodezhi, 1990. 116 s.
5.
Dem'yanov A. A. Moya sluzhba pri Vremennom Pravitel'stve // Arkhiv russkoi revolyutsii. V 22 t. M., 1991. T.6. S. 301-302.
6.
Vestnik Vremennogo pravitel'stva. 1917. № 50/96.
7.
Zavadskii S. V. Na velikom izlome (Otchet grazhdanina o perezhitom v 1916–17 godakh) // Arkhiv russkoi revolyutsii. V 22 t. M., 1991. T. 11. S. 16.
8.
Abdulin R.S. Sud, sudoustroistvo, pravosudie i sudebnoe upravlenie v Rossii v period s fevralya po oktyabr' 1917g.// Problemy pravoprimeneniya v sovremennoi Rossii: materialy nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii.Omsk.2015.S.160-179.
9.
Il'ina T.N. Politika Vremennogo pravitel'stva v sfere kadrovogo obespecheniya sudebnykh uchrezhdenii //Pravo i sotsiologiya. 2014. №7. S.15.
10.
Zhurnal Ministerstva yustitsii. 1917. № 5-6. S. 103-104.
11.
Sobranie uzakonenii i rasporyazhenii Vremennogo pravitel'stva. Pg., 1917.
12.
Zvyagintsev A. G., Orlov Yu. G. V epokhu potryasenii i reform. Rossiiskie prokurory. 1906–1917. M., 1996. S. 316–317.
13.
Grazhdanin-Ministr A. F. Kerenskii. Rechi, besedy, pis'ma. M., 1917. S. 10.
14.
Ioffe G. Z. Semnadtsatyi god: Lenin, Kerenskii, Kornilov. M., 1995. S. 37.
15.
Tokvil' A. de. Staryi poryadok i revolyutsiya. SPb. 1911. S.227
16.
Abdulin R.S. Istoki sudebnogo upravleniya (istoriko –pravovoi analiz) // Genesis: istoricheskie issledovaniya.2015.№ 6.S.692-763.
17.
Kozhevnikov M.V. Istoriya sovetskogo suda. 1917-1947 gg. M., 1948.S.
18.
Oleinik I.I. Organizatsionno-pravovye osnovy stanovleniya i razvitiya organov upravleniya yustitsiei v RSFSR (1917-1936 gg.): avtoref. diss. ... d-ra yur. nauk. Vladimir, 2006.
19.
Chistyakov O.I. Krushenie tsarizma (fevral'—oktyabr' 1917 g.) // Istoriya otechestvennogo gosudarstva i prava. M.: «Yurist''». 2006. T. 1. Glava 20.S.198-209.
20.
Dekrety Sovetskoi vlasti. T. 1. 25 oktyabrya 1917-16 marta 1918.
21.
Ministerstvo yustitsii Rossii za 200 let (1802-2002): Istoriko-pravovoi ocherk. M., 2002. S. 132.
22.
Efremova N.N. Ministerstvo yustitsii Rossiiskoi imperii. 1802-1917 gg. (Istoriko-pravovoe issledovanie). M.: Nauka, 1983.150s.
23.
GARF. F. A-353. D. 6404 (Narodnyi komissariat yustitsii RSFSR (Narkomyust RSFSR) (1917-1946)
24.
Abdulin R.S. Osnovnye organizatsionno-pravovye (sudoustroistvennye) printsipy sudebnogo upravleniya i rukovodstva sudami posle Oktyabr'skoi revolyutsii 1917 g. (istoriko-pravovoi aspekt) // Sbornik nauchnykh trudov. Kurgan: Izdatel'stvo KGU, 2004. S. 175-178.
25.
Ushakov I. A. Sozdanie pervogo narodnogo suda v Petrograde // Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i pra-vo. 1957. № 1. S. 3- 7.
26.
Stuchka P. I. Revolyutsionnaya rol' sovetskogo prava. Izd. 3-e. M., 1934. S. 91, 116;
27.
Kazakov A.I. Organy sudebnogo upravleniya RSFSR v period s 1930 po 1970 gody: diss. … kand. yur. nauk. Sverdlovsk, 1984.
28.
GARF. 1917. F. 130, op. 1, d. 1 l. 13.
29.
Rubtsov S.N., Kavetskii D.B. Traditsiya i novatsii v sudebnoi deyatel'nosti bol'shevikov pervoi poloviny 1918 g. //Rossiiskii sledovatel'. 2016. № 5.
30.
Smirnov L.N. Leninskie idei o sude i pravosudii i ikh pretvorenie v zhizn' // Sud v SSSR. M., 1977. S. 10.
31.
Efremova N.N. Evolyutsiya otechestvennogo pravosudiya (sudebnye reformy KhKh — nachalo KhKhI vv.)// Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshei shkoly ekonomiki. 2009. S.15-22.
32.
Gorodetskii E. N. Rozhdenie Sovetskogo gosudarstva. (1917-1918 gg.). M.: Nau-ka, 1987. S. 201.
33.
SU RSFSR.1917.№11. St.166.
34.
SU RSFSR. 1918. №52. St.589.
35.
Stuchka P.I. Staryi i novyi sud. Tiflis. 1919. S. 10.
36.
Kodan S.V. Yuridicheskaya politika Rossiiskogo gosudarstva (1800-1850-e gg.) : Dis. ... d-ra yurid. nauk. Ekaterinburg. 2004.
37.
SU RSFSR.1917.№12. St. 170.
38.
SU RSFSR. 1918. № 35. St.471.
39.
Reisner M. Pravo. Nashe pravo. Chuzhoe pravo. Obshchee pravo. M., 1924. S. 14.
40.
SU RSFSR. 1918g № 4. St. 50.
41.
Bukov V.A. Ot rossiiskogo suda prisyazhnykh k proletarskomu sudu. U istokov totalitarizma. M.. 1997. S. 263.
42.
SU RSFSR. 1919. № 12. St. 130.
43.
SU RSFSR. 1918. № 41. St. 520.
44.
SU RSFSR. 1918. № 26. St. 347.
45.
SU RSFSR. 1918. № 52. St. 589.
46.
Oleinik I.I. Organizatsionno-pravovye osnovy stanovleniya i razvitiya organov upravleniya yustitsiei v RSFSR (1917-1936 gg.): Diss. ... d-ra yur. nauk. Vladimir, 2006.
47.
Sud v SSSR /pod red. L.N. Smirnova, V.V. Kulikova, S.G. Bannikova, V.M. Savitskogo, Kh.B. Sheinina. M., 1977. S. 76.
48.
SU RSFSR. 1922. № 16. St. 902.
49.
SU RSFSR. 1922. № 20 – 21. St. 230.
50.
SU RSFSR. 1923. № 7. St. 106.
51.
SU RSFSR. 1920. N 83. St. 407.
52.
Sovetskaya yustitsiya. 1923. №4-5. S. 3-4.
53.
SU RSFSR. 1921. N 15. St. 97.
54.
Dekret SNK «O sude» ot 24 noyabrya 1917 (№1) // SU RSFSR. 1917. № 4. St. 50.
55.
SU RSFSR. 1919. № 10-11. St. 119.
56.
GARF. F. A-353. Op. 2. D. 2. L. 1,6; D. 113. L. 12.
57.
GARF. F. A-353. Op. 1. D. 24; Op. 2. D. 335,336.
58.
GARF. F. A-353. Op.2.D. 1.L.Z. V kompetentsiyu otdelenii vkhodili «priem i rassmotrenie zhalob na resheniya i prigovory narodnykh sudei v poryadke nadzora. Nablyudenie za pravil'nym i edinoobraznym primeneniem dekretov vo vsekh sudebnykh ustanovleniyakh…».
59.
SU RSFSR. 1920. № 90. St. 465.
60.
Makovskaya, L.P. Nachal'nyi etap stroitel'stva organov yustitsii RSFSR (1917-1922 gg.): Dis… kand. yurid. nauk. M., 1975.
61.
SU RSFSR. 1921. N 15. St. 97.
62.
Effektivnost' pravosudiya i problema ustraneniya sudebnykh oshibok: monografiya / Pod red. chl-korr. AN SSSR V.N. Kudryavtseva // Institut gosudarstva i prava Akademii nauk SSSR. 1975. S. 66-67.
63.
SU RSFSR. 1920. № 54. St. 236.
64.
SU RSFSR. 1920. №90. St. 465.
65.
Polozhenie o sudoustroistve RSFSR 1922 g. // SU RSFSR. 1922. N 69. St. 902.
66.
Polozhenie o sudoustroistve RSFSR 1922g. Razdel «O vvedenii v deistvie Polozheniya o sudoustroistve RSFSR»//SU RSFSR. 1922.№69. St.902.