Рус Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 1980,   Articles in work: 306 Declined articles: 761 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

Fairness as a Mandatory Requirement for Judicial Decision
Rundkvist Anton Nikolaevich

Lecturer of the Department of the Theory and Methodology of Law at Liberal Arts University

620041, Russia, Sverdlovskaya Oblast' oblast', g. Ekaterinburg, ul. Zheleznodorozhnikov, 3

anton-upol@mail.ru

Abstract.

The subject of the research is the Russian procedural law and judicial practice of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation regarding general requirements set forth for judicial decisions. The researcher pays attention to the evaluation of such decisios from the point of view of the general legal principle of justice. The aim of the research is to describe essential features and give a definition of the fair judicial decision. In addition, the author touches upon the problem of differentiation between private, social, public and state interests that are important for keeping the legal balance through distribution of mutual rights and responsibilities when making a fair administered justice. The author has applied the general research methods as dialectical analysis, and a number of private research methods such as analysis, induction, deduction and formal law method. The results of the research demonstrate the relationship between judicial decision that fulfils the requirements of fairness and such terms as adequacy, proportionality, legal balance, etc. The scope of the research results covers the law enforcement practice as well as procedural branches of the Russian law, in particular, the author emphasizes the need to enfroce requirements for the fairness of a judicial decision in particular articles of the Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, Arbitration Procedure Code of the Russian Federation and Administrative Procedure Code. The author of the article also gives recommendations to coordinate requirements for legality and fairness in the course of justice and offers an integrative approach to interpreting the principle of fairness taking into account the role of justice in the entire system of legal principles and legal axiomes. 

Keywords: interests of society, public interests, private interests, principle of legality, fair judicial decision, principle of justice, judicial decision, justice, state interests, legal balance

DOI:

10.25136/2409-7136.2018.6.22925

Article was received:

13-05-2017


Review date:

06-05-2017


Publish date:

04-07-2018


This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Grazhdanskii protsessual'nyi kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 14.11.2002 № 138-FZ (red. ot 19.12.2016) // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 20.11.2002. № 220.
2.
Kodeks administrativnogo sudoproizvodstva Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 08.03.2015 № 21-FZ (red. ot 28.03.2017, s izm. ot 13.04.2017) // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 11.03.2015. № 49.
3.
Arbitrazhnyi protsessual'nyi kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 24.07.2002 № 95-FZ (red. ot 19.12.2016) // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 27.07.2002. № 137.
4.
Ugolovno-protsessual'nyi kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 18.12.2001 № 174-FZ (red. ot 03.04.2017) // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 22.12.2001. № 249.
5.
Radbrukh G. Zakonnoe nepravo i nadzakonnoe pravo // Radbrukh G. Filosofiya prava / per. s nem. – M.: 2004. S. 233 – 234.
6.
Aleksi R. Ponyatie i deistvitel'nost' prava (otvet yuridicheskomu pozitivizmu) ; per. s nem. / [A. Laptev, F. Kal'shoeir] ; [V. Bergmann, pred., sost.] ; [T. Yakovleva, nauch. red.]. – M. : Infotropik Mediya, 2011. S. 157.
7.
Konventsiya o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod (Zaklyuchena v g. Rime 04.11.1950) (s izm. ot 13.05.2004) // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 08.01.2001. № 2. St. 163.
8.
Glazkova M.E. Primenenie evropeiskikh standartov otpravleniya pravosudiya v rossiiskom arbitrazhnom protsesse: monografiya [Elektronnyi resurs] // Dostup iz spravochno-pravovoi sistemy «GARANT».
9.
Reshenie ot 15.05.2007 po voprosu priemlemosti zhaloby «Dolgonosov (Dolgonosov) protiv Rossiiskoi Federatsii» // Byulleten' Evropeiskogo suda po pravam cheloveka. 2007. № 9. S. 134 – 136.
10.
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 2 fevralya 1996 goda № 4-P «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti punkta 5 chasti vtoroi stat'i 371, chasti tret'ei stat'i 374 i punkta 4 chasti vtoroi stat'i 384 Ugolovno-protsessual'nogo kodeksa RSFSR v svyazi s zhalobami grazhdan K.M. Kul'neva, V.S. Lalueva, Yu.V. Lukashova i I.P. Serebrennikova» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 15.02.1996. № 31.
11.
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 24 yanvarya 2002 goda № 3-P «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozhenii chasti vtoroi stat'i 170 i chasti vtoroi stat'i 235 Kodeksa zakonov o trude Rossiiskoi Federatsii i punkta 3 stat'i 25 Federal'nogo zakona «O professional'nykh soyuzakh, ikh pravakh i garantiyakh deyatel'nosti» v svyazi s zaprosami Zernogradskogo raionnogo suda Rostovskoi oblasti i Tsentral'nogo raionnogo suda goroda Kemerovo» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 07.02.2002. № 24.
12.
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 8 dekabrya 2003 goda № 18-P «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozhenii statei 125, 219, 227, 229, 236, 237, 239, 246, 254, 271, 378, 405 i 408, a takzhe glav 35 i 39 Ugolovno-protsessual'nogo kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii v svyazi s zaprosami sudov obshchei yurisdiktsii i zhalobami grazhdan» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 23.12.2003. № 257.
13.
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 14 iyulya 2005 goda 8-P «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti otdel'nykh polozhenii federal'nykh zakonov o federal'nom byudzhete na 2003 god, na 2004 god i na 2005 god i postanovleniya Pravitel'stva Rossiiskoi Federatsii «O poryadke ispolneniya Ministerstvom finansov Rossiiskoi Federatsii sudebnykh aktov po iskam k kazne Rossiiskoi Federatsii na vozmeshchenie vreda, prichinennogo nezakonnymi deistviyami (bezdeistviem) organov gosudarstvennoi vlasti libo dolzhnostnykh lits organov gosudarstvennoi vlasti» v svyazi s zhalobami grazhdan E.D. Zhukhovitskogo, I.G. Poima, A.V. Ponyatovskogo, A.E. Cheslavskogo i OAO "Khabarovskenergo"» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 21.07.2005. № 157.
14.
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 5 fevralya 2007 goda № 2-P «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozhenii statei 16, 20, 112, 336, 376, 377, 380, 381, 382, 383, 387, 388 i 389 Grazhdanskogo protsessual'nogo kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii v svyazi s zaprosom Kabineta Ministrov Respubliki Tatarstan, zhalobami otkrytykh aktsionernykh obshchestv «Nizhnekamskneftekhim» i «Khakasenergo», a takzhe zhalobami ryada grazhdan» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 14.02.2007. № 31.
15.
Dobrovol'skii V.I. Aktual'nye voprosy arbitrazhnogo zakonodatel'stva: o chem molchit Arbitrazhnyi protsessual'nyi kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Elektronnyi resurs] // Dostup iz spravochno-pravovoi sistemy «GARANT».
16.
Ispolnitel'noe proizvodstvo: traditsii i reformy (pod redaktsiei R. van Ree i dr.) [Elektronnyi resurs] // Dostup iz spravochno-pravovoi sistemy «GARANT».
17.
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 27 oktyabrya 2015 goda № 28-P «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti punkta 1 stat'i 836 Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii v svyazi s zhalobami grazhdan I.S. Bilera, P.A. Gur'yanova, N.A. Gur'yanovoi, S.I. Kaminskoi, A.M. Savenkova, L.I. Savenkovoi i I.P. Stepanyuginoi» // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 05.11.2015. № 249.
18.
Grazhdanskii kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii (chast' vtoraya) ot 26.01.1996 № 14-FZ (red. ot 28.03.2017) // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 06.02.1996. № 23. 07.02.1996. № 24. 08.02.1996. № 25. 10.02.1996. № 27.
19.
Postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 14.07.2005 № 9-P «Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozhenii stat'i 113 Nalogovogo kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii v svyazi s zhaloboi grazhdanki G.A. Polyakovoi i zaprosom Federal'nogo arbitrazhnogo suda Moskovskogo okruga» // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva RF. 25.07.2005. № 30 (ch. II). St. 3200.
20.
Nalogovyi kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii (chast' pervaya) ot 31.07.1998 № 146-FZ (red. ot 28.12.2016) // Rossiiskaya gazeta. 06.08.1998. № 148-149.
21.
B.B. Cherepakhin. K voprosu o chastnom i publichnom prave // X cb. trudov professorov i prepodavatelei Irkutskogo gos. un-ta. Irkutsk, 1926. C. 8–35.
22.
O razgranichenii obshchestvennykh, gosudarstvennykh, chastnykh interesov i o slozhnosti opredeleniya pervykh sm.: Semitko A. P. Prioritet prav i svobod cheloveka kak odno iz pravovykh osnovanii liberalizma // Vestnik Gumanitarnogo universiteta. – Ekaterinburg: Gumanitarnyi un-t, 2015. – № 4 (11). – S. 69–79.
23.
O kolliziyakh mezhdu razlichnymi vidami interesov sm.: Semitko A.P. Personotsentristskii podkhod k gosudarstvu i pravu i razreshenie kollizii mezhdu lichnymi, obshchestvennymi i gosudarstvennymi interesami // Yuridicheskaya tekhnika (2017. № 11). Nizhnii Novgorod. – «Kollizii zakonodatel'nykh, interpretatsionnykh, pravoprimenitel'nykh aktov: doktrina, praktika, tekhnika preodoleniya» (762 s.). — S. 298-301.
24.
Kurbatov A.Ya. Zashchita prav i zakonnykh interesov v usloviyakh «modernizatsii» pravovoi sistemy Rossii / A.Ya. Kurbatov. — M.: Yustitsinform, 2013. — 172 s