Рус Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 1870,   Articles in work: 317 Declined articles: 768 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

Cooperation of Ho Chi Minh with American Special Services and the Formation of Soviet-Vietnamese Relations
Zusmanovich Dmitry Dmitriyevich

PhD in History

Lecturer, Department of Disciplines of the Humanities, Moscow Finance and Law University

117342, Russia, Moskovskaya oblast', g. Moscow, ul. Vvedenskogo, d.1A, Kafedra gumanitarnykh distsiplin

hostel306a@rambler.ru
Другие публикации этого автора
 

 

Abstract.

The article addresses the little-known aspects of Soviet-Vietnamese relations and the biography of Ho Chi Minh. The subject of this study is the direction of the foreign policy of the military-political leadership of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam in the period from 1945-1950. With the August Revolution, Ho Chi Minh and his associates came to power in Vietnam. The choice of foreign policy direction was not as straightforward for the Vietnamese leadership as Soviet historiography has claimed. With the help of new sources, such as the "Pentagon Documents", documents from the archive of the CIA, as well as Russian archives, it has become possible to study the formative process of the foreign policy direction of the Democratic Republic of Vietnam and the process of choosing an ally for this state. The author dedicates considerable attention to Ho Chi Minh's cooperation with US intelligence agents as a little-known episode, especially in Russian historiography. In the course of researching this topic, the author used the historical-genetic method, the principles of historicism and objectivity. In addition to the above-named principles, the approach from the positions of Hans Morgenthau's political realism and Kenneth Waltz's neo-realism was also applied. Vietnam, like any other state, sought to realize its national interests, but under the conditions of the beginning of the Cold War and the formation of a "bipolar world", this aspiration depended on the general structure of the global balance of power. Having analyzed the new array of sources, the author comes to the conclusion that under certain conditions, Vietnam could have followed the capitalist path of development, thus becoming a neutral state or even an ally of the United States.

Keywords: South-Eastern Asia, Communist International, H. Truman, Viet Minh, "Pentagon Documents", August Revolution, Ho Chi Minh, Office of Strategic Services, First Indochina War, Soviet-Vietnamese relations

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0609.2018.1.24021

Article was received:

04-09-2017


Review date:

28-08-2017


Publish date:

10-03-2018


This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Bukharkin I. V. Kreml' i Kho Shi Min. 1945-1969 gg. // Novaya i Noveishaya istoriya 1998 . №3. str. 125-141.
2.
Sokolov A. A. Komintern i V'etnam. Podgotovka v'etnamskikh politicheskikh kadrov v kommunisticheskikh vuzakh SSSR, 20-30-e gg.. M., IV RAN, 1998. 180 s.
3.
Ognetov I. A. Na v'etnamskom napravlenii. M., Gumanitarii, 2007. 322 s.
4.
Konoreva I. A. Sovetskii Soyuz i Indokitai: 1943-1976. Kursk, Izd-vo Kurskogo gos. un-ta, 2011. 369 s.
5.
Selivanov I. N. Stalin, Kho Shi Min i «delo» Chan Ngok Dana: fakty, gipotezy, arkhivnye dokumenty. Kursk, Kurskii gos. un-t, 2014. 269 s.
6.
Sovetskii Soyuz-V'etnam 30 let otnoshenii, 1950-1980. Dokumenty i materialy. M., Politizdat, 1982. 792 s.
7.
Kobelev E. V. Kho Shi Min. M., Mol. gvardiya, 1979. 364 s.
8.
Afonin S. N., Kobelev E.V. Tovarishch Kho Shi Min. M., Politizdat, 1980. 239 s.
9.
Duiker W. Ho Chi Minh. N.Y., Hyperion cop, 2000. 695 r.
10.
Fenn C. Ho Chi Minh. L., Vista Cop., 1973. 144 r.
11.
Warbey W. Ho Chi Minh and the struggle for an independent Vietnam. L., Merlin press Cop., 1972. 274 r.
12.
Mikheev Yu. Ya. Amerikantsy v Indokitae. Kritika protivopravnoi doktriny i politiki SShA. M., Mezhdunar. otnosheniya, 1972. 477 s.
13.
Divil'kovskii S. I., Ognetov I.A. Put' k pobede. Ocherk bor'by za nats. nezavisimost', edinstvo, mir i sotsializm vo V'etname (1945-1976), M., Politizdat, 1978. 278 s.
14.
Pentagon Papers [Part I] Vietnam and the U.S., 1940-1950. // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: https://nara-media-001.s3.amazonaws.com/arcmedia/research/pentagon-papers/Pentagon-Papers-Part-I.pdf (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
15.
Prados J. Vietnam. The History of an Unwinnable War, 1945-1975. Lawrence, Kan., Univ. press of Kansas, cop. 2009. 665 r.
16.
Tegeran-Yalta-Potsdam. Sbornik dokumentov [trekh konferentsii stran antigitlerovskoi koalitsii]. M., Mezhdunar. otnosheniya, 1970. 295 s.
17.
Schlesinger A. The bitter heritage. L., Deutsch, 1967. 127 r.
18.
Erofeev N. A. Zakat Britanskoi imperii. M., Mysl', 1967. 277 s.
19.
Pechatnov V. O., Mynykin A.S. Istoriya vneshnei politiki SShA. M., Mezhdunar. otnosheniya, 2012. 672 s.
20.
Mid U. R. Vlast', terror, mir i voina. Bol'shaya strategiya Ameriki v obshchestve riska /Per. s angl. A. Georgieva, M. Nazarovoi. M., Progress-Traditsiya, 2006. 208 s.
21.
Utkin A. I. Mirovaya Kholodnaya voina. M., Eksmo, 2005. 732 s.
22.
Lawrenece M. The First Vietnam War : colonial conflict and cold war crisis. Cambridge, Mass.; Harvard univ. press, 2007. 374 r.
23.
Anderson D. Trapped by success. N.Y., Columbia univ.press, 1991. 276 r.
24.
Foreign Relations of the United States, 1946, The Far East, Volume VIII, document 72. The Ambassador in France ( Caffery ) to the Secretary of State. // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: : https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1946v08/d72 (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
25.
Vietnam and America A doc. history. Ed. by Gettleman M., Franklin J., Young V., Franklin B. N.Y., Grove press, 1985. 524 r.
26.
Cooper C. The lost crusade. N.Y., Dodd, Mead & co., 1970. 559 r.
27.
Irving R. The first Indochina war. L., Helm, 1975. 169 r.
28.
Pike D. History of Vietnamese communism, 1925-1976. Stanford (Calif.). Hoover institution press Cop., 1978. 181 r.
29.
Direktivy i proekt pis'ma Vostochnogo sekretariata IKKI. 1 fevralya 1933 g. – 1 noyabrya 1933 g. // RGASPI. F. 495. Op. 154. D. 577. // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: http://sovdoc.rusarchives.ru/#showunit&id=213828 (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
30.
Ognetov I. A. Maloizvestnye aspekty sovetsko-v'etnamskikh otnoshenii // Voprosy istorii. 2001. № 8. str. 134-139.
31.
Pike D. Vietnam and the Soviet Union Anatomy of an alliance. L., Westview press, 1987. 271 r.
32.
Zametki o polozhenii v kompartii Indokitaya i manifest KP. 25 iyunya 1940 g. – 27 iyunya 1940 g. RGASPI. F. 495. Op. 14. D. 404 // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: http://sovdoc.rusarchives.ru/#showunit&id=200876 (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
33.
Konoreva I. A., Selivanov I.N. Dokumental'naya istoriya sovetsko-v'etnamskikh otnoshenii: 1945-1955 (k 65-letiyu sovetsko-v'etnamskikh diplomaticheskikh otnoshenii). Kursk, Kurskii gos. un-t, 2016. 267.
34.
Ognetov I. A. Kho Shi Min priletel v Moskvu pryamo iz dzhunglei // Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn' 2003. №8. str. 128-140.
35.
V'etmin' – Liga Bor'by za nezavisimost' V'etnama. Kratkaya spravka. // AVP RF. F. 079. Op. 2, P. 1. D. 4.
36.
Bogaturov A. D. Velikie derzhavy na Tikhom okeane. M., Konvert. 1997. 349 s.
37.
Mkhitaryan S. A. Istoriya V'etnama v Noveishee vremya (1917-1965). M., Nauka, 1970. 477 s.
38.
Young M. A Sompanion to the Vietnam War. Malden (MA). Blackwell, 2002. 514 r.
39.
Major problems in the history of the Vietnam war. Lexington, etc. Heath, 1990. 635 r.
40.
Foreign Relations of the United States, 1946, The Far East, Volume VIII, document 71. The Acting Secretary of State to the Consul at Saigon ( Reed). // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1946v08/d71 (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
41.
Foreign Relations of the United States, 1946, The Far East, Volume VIII, document 81. The Ambassador in France ( Caffery ) to the Secretary of State. // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1946v08/d81 (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
42.
CIA Library. Soviet Advisors to the Viet Minh // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP82-00457R000700020011-4.pdf (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
43.
Qiang Zhai China and The Vietnam Wars 1950-1970. Chapel Hill and London, The University of North Carolina Press, 2000.
44.
Iz dnevnika Poslannika SSSR v Shveitsarii A.G. Kulazhennakova. Beseda s Zamestitelem gosudarstvennogo sekretarya pri prezidenture Soveta Ministrov Respubliki V'etnam Fam No Makhom. 9 sentyabrya 1947 g. // AVP RF. F.079 Op. 1, P. 1, D.1.
45.
Ognetov I. A. Maloizvestnye aspekty sovetsko-v'etnamskikh otnoshenii // Voprosy istorii 2001. №8. str. 134-139.
46.
Indokitai. Spravka. // AVP RF F. 079 Op. 9, P. 7, D. 16.
47.
Pentagon Papers [Part V. B. 2. a.] Justification of the War. Internal Documents. The Truman Administration. Volume I: 1945-1949 // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: https://nara-media-001.s3.amazonaws.com/arcmedia/research/pentagon-papers/Pentagon-Papers-Part-V-B-2a.pdf (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
48.
Ekspansionistskaya politika SShA v Indokitae. Sostavil II sekretar' otdela YuVA S. A. Mkhitaryan. // AVP RF. F. 079. Op. 4, P. 2, D. 9.
49.
Lawrence M. The Vietnam War. N.Y., Oxford University Press, 2008. 214 r.
50.
Amerikanskaya agressivnaya politika vo V'etname. Sostavil II sekretar' otdela YuVA S. A. Mkhitaryan. 30 yanvarya 1950 g. // AVP RF. F. 79 Op. 4, P. 1. D. 4.
51.
Gaiduk I. V. Confronting Vietnam: Soviet policy toward the Indochina Conflict, 1954-1963. Washington, Stanford university press, 2003. 286 r.
52.
Galenovich Yu. M. Stalin i Mao. Dva vozhdya. M., Vostochnaya kniga, 2009. 574 s.
53.
Khrushchev N. S. Vremya, lyudi, vlast': (Vospominaniya): v 4-kh knigakh. Kn-3. M., Mosk. novosti, 1999. 703 s.
54.
Selivanov I. N. Kho Shi Min. Kontakty v 1950-1952 gg. // Voprosy istorii 2012. №8. str. 3-13.
55.
CIA Library. Chinese Communist and Soviet Military Aid to the Viet Minh // [Elektronnyi resurs] – URL: https://www.cia.gov/library/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP82-00457R007100400002-1.pdf (data obrashcheniya 24.08.2017)
56.
Devidson F. Voina vo V'etname (1946-1975 gg.).M. Izografus, 2002. 814 s.