Рус Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 1897,   Articles in work: 302 Declined articles: 798 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

The Faidas of Late Medieval Catholic Parishes
Leonova Tatiana Alekseevna

PhD in History

Associate Professor, Department of General History and Cultural Heritage, M. Akmulla Bashkir State Pedagogical University

450076, Russia, respublika Bashkortostan, g. Ufa, ul. Aksakova, 7, kv. 165

leonotan@mail.ru

Abstract.

The subject of this research is the conflicts between laity and clergy, known in historical literature under the name of "faidas", as a commonplace phenomenon in Catholic parishes during the Middle Ages. The study examines two types of conflicts in parishes: conflicts as a result of a struggle to preserve the customs of local communities and conflicts of interpersonal relations between flock and shepherd. The author analyzes the arguments of modern Medievalists regarding the concept of anti-clerical and pro-clerical sentiments of the laity in conflict situation in parishes. The study is based on documents contained in episcopal registers of the 13th-15th centuries, in ecclesiastical and lay courts. The author sets out to undo the stabilized views concerning confrontations between state and church, taken to the lower strata of Medieval society. The article's research is based on the methods of historicism and the use of the historical-genetic method and the interdisciplinary approach, which take into account the historical context not only from the point of view of the approaching Reformation but also the persistent mental attitudes generated by the corporate connections within the Medieval society. The main conclusions drawn from the conducted research is the affirmation that the relationship between priests and laymen is not only a complex but also always an unstable phenomenon. This relationship reflected both the prevailing views of society on the status of the priest, as well as the particularities tied to the specific circumstances of the parish life of local communities in which parish clergymen had integrated. The scientific novelty of this study is that the author established that the conflicts in parish life were not the normal behavior of the clergy at those parishes. Neither the nature of the confrontation of the members of the conflict, nor their quantity, nor the systemic action of both sides are not evidence of a widespread popular anti-ecclesiastical attitude on the eve of the Reformation.

Keywords: Middle Ages, Catholic parish, laity, local community, secular clergy, priest, clerics, visitation, ecclesiastical court, faida

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0609.2017.6.24123

Article was received:

17-09-2017


Review date:

10-09-2017


Publish date:

13-02-2018


This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Gutnova E. V. Klassovaya bor'ba i obshchestvennoe soznanie krest'yanstva v srednevekovoi Zapadnoi Evrope (XI – XV vv.). M.: Nauka, 1984. 352 s.
2.
Leonova T. A. Sobstvennost' i dokhody angliiskoi tserkvi vo vtoroi polovine XIV v. // Srednie veka. M.: Nauka, 1985. Vyp. 48. S. 214–232.
3.
Armstrong-Partida M. Conflict in the parish: antagonistic relations between clerics and parishioners//A companion to pastoral care in the Late Middle Ages (1200-1500). Leiden, 2010. P. 173-212.
4.
Aston M. Thomas Arundel. A study of church life in the reign of Richard II. Oxford, 1967.
5.
Brown A. Church and Society in England, 1000 – 1500. Palgrave, 2003. 253 p.
6.
Butler S. M. Sacred people, sacred space: evidence of parish respect and contempt toward the prereformation clergy// Canadian Journal of History, 47.1, 2012. P.1-27.
7.
Calendar of entries in the Papal registers relating to Great Britain and Ireland. Petitions to the Pope, A. D. 1342-1419 / Ed. by W. H. Bliss. Vol. 1. London, 1896.
8.
A Calendar of the Register of Richard Scrope archbishop of York, 1398-1405// Ed. R. Swanson. Univ. of York, 1981.
9.
Complaint of parishioners of Burmington against their chaplain (1484)// Pastors and the care of souls in medieval England / Edited by John Skinners and William J.Dohar. Notre Dame, 1998. P. 268-271.
10.
Concilia Magnae Britanniae et Hiberniae ab anno 1268 ad 1349. Vol. 2. Londini, 1731.
11.
Coulton G. G. Life in the Middle Ages/Selected transl. and annot. 4 v. in one. Cambr. Univ. press, 1954.
12.
Dohar W. J. The Black Death and Pastoral Leadership. The Diocese of Hereford in the Fourteenth Century. Philadelphia, 1994.
13.
Houston R. A. People, space, and law in Late Medieval and Early Modern Britain // Past and Present. No. 230. February 2016. P. 47-90.
14.
Hugh M. T. The Secular Clergy in England, 1066 – 1216. Oxford, 2014. 480p.
15.
Hughes J. Pastor and visionaries. Religion and secular life in Late Medieval Yorkshire. Rohester, 2002.
16.
Jansen K. L. “Pro bono pacis”: crime, conflict, and dispute resolution. The evidence of notarial peace contracts in Late Medieval Florence // Speculum. A Journal of Medieval Studies. 2013. Vol. 88, No.2. P. 427 – 456.
17.
The Episcopal Register of Robert Rege, ordinis Predicatorum, lord Bishop of Chichester, 1397–1415 / Ed. by C. Deedes. P.I. London: Mitchel Hughes and Clarke, 1908.
18.
Kűmin B. A. The English parish in a European perspective // The Parish in English life, 1400-1600/Ed.by K. L. French, G.G. Gibbs, B.A. Kűmin.-Manchester, New York, 1997. P.15-32.
19.
Martin C. T. Clerical life in the fifteenth century as illustrated by proceedings of the court of chancery // Pastors and the care of souls in medieval England / Edited by John Skinners and William J.Dohar. Notre Dame, 1998. P. 271-285.
20.
Parish chaplains and their duties: episcopal rules for the clergy of Lynn (1373) // Pastors and the care of souls in medieval England / Edited by John Skinners and William J. Dohar. Notre Dame, 1998. P. 104-108.
21.
Prestwich M. Plantagenet England. Oxford, 2005.
22.
The Register of Thomas Appleby, bishop of Carlisle. 1363-1395 / Ed. by R.L. Storey. Vol.1. Rochester, 2006.
23.
The Register of Thomas Brantingham bishop of Exeter. A.D. 1370-1394. Part I. By the rev. F. C. Hingeston – Randolph. London, 1901.
24.
Spenser H. L. English preaching in the late Middle Ages. Oxford, 2002.
25.
Swanson R. N. Religion and devotion in Europe c. 1215 – 1515. New York, Cambridge University Press, 2004. 378 p.
26.
Tanner N. P. The Church in the Late Medieval Norwich. 1370-1532. Political Institute of Medieval Studies. Toronto,1984.
27.
Taubman A. W. Clergy and Commoners: interactions between medieval clergy and laity in a regional context. Submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. University of York. Centre for Medieval Studies, 2009. P. 283. http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/791/1/Thesis_Final.pdf
28.
Weale C. A. Patronage Priest and Parish in the Archdeaconry of Huntingdon 1109-1547. Middlesex University London, 1996. 367 p. Available from Middlesex University’s Research Repository at http://eprints.mdx.ac.uk/13500/
29.
William of Pagula’s Oculus Sacerdotis. A pastoral compendium: an excerpt from William of Pagula’s Oculus Sacerdotis (The Priest’s Eye) (c.1320 – 23) // Pastors and the care of souls in medieval England / Edited by John Skinners and William J. Dohar. Notre Dame, 1998. P.138 – 151.