Рус Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 2038,   Articles in work: 265 Declined articles: 863 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

Perspectives for Implementing Part 1 of Article 6.21 of The Code of the Russian Federation on Administrative Offences in Relation to the Decisions of The European Court on Human Rights of June 20, 2017 Regarding the Case 'Baev and Others against the Russian Federation' (Complaints 67667/09, 44092/12, 56717/12)
Gorian Ella

PhD in Law

Docent, Vladivostok State University of Economics and Service

690014, Russia, Primorsky Krai, Vladivostok, Gogolya Street 41, office #5502

ella-gorjan@yandex.ru
Другие публикации этого автора
 

 
Netrusov Yurii

 Paralegal, Clayton Utz Melbourne (Australia), LL.B, LL.M. (McGeorge School of Law), J.D. (Melbourne Law School)

3053, Avstraliya, g. Carlton, ul. Elgin Street, 192A

inetrusov@student.unimelb.edu.au
Abstract. The authors of this article analyze the problems and perspectives of implementing provisions of the Russian law prohibiting propaganda of non-traditional sexual relations relations to the underaged taking into account decisions made by The European Court of Human Rights. The authors touch upon approaches and arguments of international and national judicial authorities and analyze judicial practice o fRussian courts on implementing the provisions of The European Court on Human Rights on restriction of rights and discrimination. The authors deine drawbacks of the Russian law prohibiting propaganda of non-traditional sexual relations to the underaged. The methodological basis of the research includes system-structure, formal-logical and hermeneutical methods. Special law methods used by the authors included cmparative law and formal law methods. Based on the authors, Russian Federation courts tend to ignore arguments of The European Court on Human Rights and demonstrate a conservative approach appealing to traditional values and religious morals while ignoring scientifically proved facts. The European Court on Human Rights' approach is based on facts about society's development and modernization of social relations as well as scientifically proved data. The term 'non-traditional sexual relations' used by the Russian legislation is also very contradictory and not defined by the law in full which makes it difficult to implement the provisions of the law and violates the principle of legal certainty. The decision would be to exclude the provisions prohibiting propaganda of non-traditional sexual relations to the underaged from the shere of law. 
Keywords: sexual orientation, freedom of expression, implementation, discrimination, human rights, homosexuality, propaganda, margin of appreciation, public order, restriction of rights
DOI: 10.7256/2454-0595.2017.12.24819
Article was received: 28-11-2017

Review date: 02-12-2017

Publish date: 16-01-2018

This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here.

References
1.
Case of Bayev and others v. Russia (Applications nos. 67667/09 and 2 others-see appended list) : Judgment, 20 June 2017 // European Court of Human Rights : ofitsial'nyi sait. [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{"itemid":["001-174422"]} (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
2.
O zhalobakh «Baev i drugie protiv Rossii» i «Davydov i drugie protiv Rossii» // Ministerstvo yustitsii RF : ofitsial'nyi sait. [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://minjust.ru/ru/novosti/o-zhalobah-baev-i-drugie-protiv-rossii-i-davydov-i-drugie-protiv-rossii (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
3.
Kodeks Rossiiskoi Federatsii ob administrativnykh pravonarusheniyakh : federal'nyi zakon ot 30.12.2001 №195-FZ (red. ot 30.10.2017) // SPS «Konsul'tantPlyus». [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_34661/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
4.
O zashchite detei ot informatsii, prichinyayushchei vred ikh zdorov'yu i razvitiyu : federal'nyi zakon ot 29.12.2010 №436-FZ (red. ot 01.05.2017) // SPS «Konsul'tantPlyus». [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_108808 (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
5.
O primenenii sudami obshchei yurisdiktsii Konventsii o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod ot 4 noyabrya 1950 goda i Protokolov k nei : postanovlenie Plenuma Verkhovnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii № 21 ot 27 iyunya 2013 g. // Verkhovnyi sud Rossiiskoi Federatsii : ofitsial'nyi sait [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://www.vsrf.ru/Show_pdf.php?Id=8717 (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
6.
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti polozhenii stat'i 1 Federal'nogo zakona «O ratifikatsii Konventsii o zashchite prav cheloveka i osnovnykh svobod i protokolov k nei», punktov 1 i 2 stat'i 32 Federal'nogo zakona «O mezhdunarodnykh dogovorakh Rossiiskoi Federatsii», chastei pervoi i chetvertoi stat'i 11, punkta 4 chasti chetvertoi stat'i 392 Grazhdanskogo protsessual'nogo kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii, chastei 1 i 4 stat'i 13, punkta 4 chasti 3 stat'i 311 Arbitrazhnogo protsessual'nogo kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii, chastei 1 i 4 stat'i 15, punkta 4 chasti 1 stat'i 350 Kodeksa administrativnogo sudoproizvodstva Rossiiskoi Federatsii i punkta 2 chasti chetvertoi stat'i 413 Ugolovno-protsessual'nogo kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii v svyazi s zaprosom gruppy deputatov Gosudarstvennoi dumy : postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 14 iyulya 2015 g. №21-P // SPS «Konsul'tantPlyus». [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_182936/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
7.
Fedotova Yu.E. Stat'ya 6.21 Kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii ob administrativnykh pravonarusheniyakh: problemy tolkovaniya / Yu.E. Fedotova // Rossiiskoe pravo: obrazovanie, praktika, nauka.-2017.-№1(97).-S. 58-59.
8.
Suponina E.A. Administrativnaya otvetstvennost' za propagandu sredi nesovershennoletnikh netraditsionnykh seksual'nykh otnoshenii: problemy i perspektivy / E.A. Suponina // NovaInfo.Ru.-2016.-T. 1.-№52.-S. 198-203.
9.
Bashveeva T.V., Donchenko A.G. Predely ugolovno-pravovogo vozdeistviya za propagandu netraditsionnykh seksual'nykh otnoshenii sredi nesovershennoletnikh / T.V. Bashveeva, A.G. Donchenko // Konstitutsionnye i administrativno-pravovye osnovy rossiiskoi gosudarstvennosti: istoriya, sovremennost' i perspektivy razvitiya: sb. material. zaoch. Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf. / Pod obshch. red. V.V. Andreeva, A.G. Petrova.-2015.-S. 25-29.
10.
Shchetikhina D.A. K voprosu o diskriminatsii po priznaku seksual'noi orientatsii / D.A. Shchetikhina // Aktual'nye napravleniya nauchnykh issledovanii XXI veka: teoriya i praktika.-2015.-T.3.-№1(12).-S. 418-423.
11.
Bartenev D.G., Kirichenko K.A. Zapret propagandy netraditsionnykh seksual'nykh otnoshenii v otsenke Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossii: predrassudki snova pobedili pravo / D.G. Bartenev, K.A. Kirichenko // Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie.-2014.-№6(103).-S. 132-143.
12.
Kryazhkova O.N. Novyi raund bor'by za prava seksual'nykh men'shinstv: kommentarii k postanovleniyu Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossii ot 23 sentyabrya 2014 goda № 24-p / O.N. Kryazhkova // Sravnitel'noe konstitutsionnoe obozrenie.-2014.-№6(103).-S. 123-131.
13.
Kon I.S. Gomofobiya kak lakmusovaya bumazhka rossiiskoi demokratii / I.S. Kon // Vestnik obshchestvennogo mneniya. Dannye. Analiz. Diskussii.-2007.-№4(90).-S. 59-69.
14.
Kortunov V.V., Zorina N.M., Sotsiokul'turnye i mirovozzrencheskie istoki gomofobii v Rossii / V.V. Kortunov, N.M. Zorina, O.N. Krasnova, S.A. Kokotov // Servis plus.-2015.-T. 9.-№4.-S. 91-104.
15.
Melkov S.V. Problema psikhologicheskoi pomoshchi gomoseksual'nym podrostkam / S.V. Melkov // Razvitie lichnosti.-2016.-№2.-S. 101-118.
16.
Kalinskii I.V., Chervonyuk V.I. Predely implementatsii reshenii ESPCh i fenomen diffuzii evropeiskogo (mezhdunarodnogo) prava / I.V. Kalinskii, V.I. Chervonyuk // Vestnik ekonomicheskoi bezopasnosti.-2017.-№3.-S. 26-33.
17.
Lyubin I.V. Nedostatki mekhanizma ogranicheniya ispolneniya reshenii ESPCh v Rossiiskoi Federatsii / I.V. Lyubin // Peterburgskii yurist.-2017.-№1.-S. 150-157.
18.
Breuer M. Implementing ECtHR judgments in so-called “multipolar fundamental rights situations” / M. Breuer // Zhurnal Sibirskogo federal'nogo universiteta. Seriya: Gumanitarnye nauki.-2016.-T.10.-№6.-S. 851-858.
19.
Knyazev S.D. Obyazatel'nost' postanovlenii ESPCh v pravovoi sisteme Rossii (na osnove praktiki Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii) / S.D. Knyazev // Zhurnal rossiiskogo prava.-2016.-№12(240).-S. 5-17.
20.
Syrneva Yu.K., Bogus D.A. Pravovoi dialog Evropeiskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka i Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii / Yu.K. Syrneva, D.A. Bogus // Fundamental'nye i prikladnye nauchnye issledovaniya: aktual'nye voprosy, dostizheniya i innovatsii: sb. statei pobeditelei mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf.-MTsNS «Nauka i Prosveshchenie».-2016.-S. 227-234.
21.
Dubinin M.G. Pozitsiya Konstitutsionnogo Suda v voprosakh sootnosheniya Konstitutsii Rossiiskoi Federatsii i postanovlenii Evropeiskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka / M.G. Dubinin // Pravo i praktika.-2015.-№4.-S. 36-42.
22.
Case of Alekseyev v. Russia (Applications nos. 4916/07, 25924/08 and 14599/09) : Judgment, 21 October 2010// European Court of Human Rights : ofitsial'nyi sait. [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{"itemid":["001-101257"]} (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
23.
"Human Rights Watch" kritikuet zapret gei-parada v Moskve, 28 fevralya 2006 g. // Interfaks-Religiya : ofitsial'nyi sait. [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://interfax-religion.ru/?act=news&div=9804 (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
24.
Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)5 of the Committee of Ministers to member states on measures to combat discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity (Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 31 March 2010 at the 1081st meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies) // Council of Europe : ofitsial'nyi sait. [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: https://search.coe.int/cm/Pages/result_details.aspx?ObjectID=09000016805cf40a (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
25.
Po delu o proverke konstitutsionnosti chasti 1 stat'i 6.21 Kodeksa Rossiiskoi Federatsii ob administrativnykh pravonarusheniyakh v svyazi s zhaloboi grazhdan N.A.Alekseeva, Ya.N.Evtushenko i D.A.Isakova : postanovlenie Konstitutsionnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 23 sentyabrya 2014 goda №24-P // SPS «Konsul'tantPlyus». [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://www.consultant.ru/document/Cons_doc_LAW_169047/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
26.
Kabanov P.A. Nesovershennoletnie zhertvy sovremennoi rossiiskoi prestupnosti: statistiko-viktimologicheskoe izmerenie (2009-2015 gg. ) / P.A. Kabanov // Viktimologiya. – 2016.-№3(9). – S. 7-23.
27.
Khavanskii S. Zapret propagandy gomoseksualizma v svete sudebnoi praktiki / S. Khavanskii // SPS «Garant». [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://www.garant.ru/ia/opinion/havanskij/479268/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
28.
Reshenie № 2A-1880/2017 2A-1880/2017~M-1438/2017 M-1438/2017 ot 18 maya 2017 g. po delu № 2A-1880/2017 (Achinskii gorodskoi sud (Krasnoyarskii krai)) // SUDAKT : ofitsial'nyi sait [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://sudact.ru/regular/doc/1UHLBjMG8u6J/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
29.
Reshenie № 2A-216/2017 2A-216/2017~M-214/2017 M-214/2017 ot 23 iyunya 2017 g. po delu № 2A-216/2017 (Kalyazinskii raionnyi sud (Tverskaya oblast')) // SUDAKT : ofitsial'nyi sait [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://sudact.ru/regular/doc/Z6yiOy8hvjQN/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
30.
Reshenie № 2A-698/2017 2A-698/2017~M-389/2017 M-389/2017 ot 29 marta 2017 g. po delu № 2A-698/2017 (Birobidzhanskii raionnyi sud Evreiskoi avtonomnoi oblasti (Evreiskaya avtonomnaya oblast')) // SUDAKT : ofitsial'nyi sait [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://sudact.ru/regular/doc/HElFk12Xwo5K/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
31.
Reshenie № 2A-216/2017 2A-216/2017~M-214/2017 M-214/2017 ot 23 iyunya 2017 g. po delu № 2A-216/2017 (Kalyazinskii raionnyi sud (Tverskaya oblast')) // SUDAKT : ofitsial'nyi sait [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://sudact.ru/regular/doc/Z6yiOy8hvjQN/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017).
32.
Reshenie № 2A-4275/2016 2A-4275/2016~M-4802/2016 M-4802/2016 ot 19 dekabrya 2016 g. po delu № 2A-4275/2016 (Sovetskii raionnyi sud g.Tomska (Tomskaya oblast')) // SUDAKT : ofitsial'nyi sait [Elektronnyi resurs]. – Rezhim dostupa: http://sudact.ru/regular/doc/5jFg9w5t5cr6/ (data obrashcheniya – 21.11.2017)