Рус Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 1862,   Articles in work: 317 Declined articles: 768 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

The Question of the Exclusion of Bishops from the House of Lords of Great Britain in 1830-1840 (Based on Journalistic Materials, the Press, Parliamentary Debates)
Petrova Tatiana

PhD Candidate, Section of Modern and Current History of Countries of Europe and America, History Department, Lomonosov Moscow State University

119991, GSP-1, Russia, g. Moscow, ul. Lomonosovskii pr-T, 27, str. 4

petrova-hist@rambler.ru

Abstract.

The subject of this article is the public and parliamentary discussions concerning the issue of the withdrawal of bishops belonging to the Church of England from among the ranks of legislators. The object of this study is the course of these discussions, their connection with the overall political context, and the arguments of the supporters of the idea of excluding prelates from parliament. The discussion was most often conducted within the framework of the general debate on church reform which had been developing since the 1780s and which became particularly relevant in the 1830s when the position of the Church was undermined by three acts of the "constitutional revolution". The aim of this work is to investigate how the idea of excluding bishops from the House of Lords appeared in English journalism, press and parliamentary debates of 1830-1840, to examine the arguments of its supporters, and to reveal its connection with the political life of the period. The methodological basis of this work are the principles of historicism and scientific objectivity, and other specific scientific methods: the historical-genetic and the historical-typological approaches. The goal itself set before the author determines the scientific novelty of the article. Some sources are utilized for the first time in Russian historiography. The author comes to the conclusions that: the idea of excluding bishops from the House of Lords was closely connected to the idea of reducing the influence of the executive power on the parliament; it was defended by appealing to both religious and political arguments, as well as through historical arguments and appeals to public opinion; it was used as an instrument of political pressure on prelates during the "constitutional revolution"; it was not supported by the government and did not have strong support among the legislators of that time.

Keywords: economical reform, parliamentary reform, Lords Spiritual, House of Lords, British Parliament, the episcopacy, Church of England, church reform, the constitutional revolution, anticlericalism

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0609.2018.2.25738

Article was received:

02-04-2018


Review date:

25-03-2018


Publish date:

05-04-2018


This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Kondrat'ev S. V. Angliiskaya revolyutsiya XVII veka. M., 2010.
2.
King P. The Episcopate during the Civil Wars, 1642–1649 // English Historical Review. 1968. Vol. 83. № 328. P. 523–537.
3.
Brose O. J. Church and Parliament. The Reshaping of the Church of England, 1828-1860. London, 1959.
4.
Best G. F. A. Temporal Pillars. Queen Anne's Bounty, the Ecclesiastical Commissioners and the Church of England. Cambridge, 1964.
5.
Virgin P. The Church in an Age of Negligence: Ecclesiastical Structure and Problems of Church Reform, 1700–1840.Cambridge, 1989.
6.
Christie I. R. The Yorkshire Association, 1780–4: A Study in Political Organization // The Historical Journal. 1960. Vol. 3. № 2. P. 144–161.
7.
Innes J. ‘Reform’ in English Public Life: the Fortunes of a Word // Rethinking the Age of Reform, 1780–1850. Cambridge, 2003. P. 71–97.
8.
Reitan E. A. The Civil List in Eighteenth-Century British Politics: Parliamentary Supremacy versus the Independence of the Crown // The Historical Journal. 1966. Vol. 9. № 3. P. 318–337.
9.
Burns A. English ‘Church Reform’ Revisited, 1780–1840 // Rethinking the Age of Reform, 1780–1850. Cambridge, 2003. P. 136–162.
10.
Watson R. A Letter to His Grace the Archbishop of Canterbury. London, 1783.
11.
The National Churches in Local Perspective: The Church of England and the Regions, 1660–1800. Woodbridge, 2003.
12.
Mathieson W. L. English Church Reform, 1815–1840. London, 1923.
13.
Williams J. Clerical Reform; or, England’s Salvation; Shewing Its Necessity by a Comparative State of the Landed Property, in Respect to Taxes, Funds, Mortgages, Tithes, Etc. With a Plan of Annihilating Forty Million of the National Debt, by a Sale of the Mortmain Lands, and a Total Abolition of Tithes. London, 1792.
14.
Russell A. The Clerical Profession. London, 1984.
15.
Solov'eva T. S. Religioznaya politika liberal'nykh tori v Anglii (20-e gg. XIX v.). M., 2000.
16.
Stetskevich M. S. «Konstitutsionnaya revolyutsiya» v Anglii v 1828–1832 gg. // Politika i kul'tura stran Evropy i Ameriki. Ioshkar-Ola, 1994. Ch. 1. S. 85–95.
17.
Stetskevich E. S., Stetskevich M. S. «Konstitutsionnaya revolyutsiya» v Anglii (1828–1832) i anglikanskii episkopat // Upravlencheskoe konsul'tirovanie. 2015. № 4. S. 183–190.
18.
Stetskevich M. S. Religiya i politiki v Anglii 1820-kh godov: konstitutsionnye reformy // Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta. Seriya 6. Filosofiya, politologiya, sotsiologiya, psikhologiya, pravo, mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. 2004. № 4. S. 44–52.
19.
Best G. F. A. The Constitutional Revolution, 1828–32 and its Consequences for the Established Church // Theology. 1959. Vol. 62. P. 226–234.
20.
Petrova T. V. Proekty tserkovnoi reformy v angliiskikh pamfletakh i traktatakh 1828–1832 godov // Nauchnyi dialog. 2016. № 2 (50). S. 283–295.
21.
Acaster J. Remedies for the Church in Danger: or Hints to the Legislature on Church Reform. London, 1830.
22.
Beverley R. M. A Letter to His Grace the Archbishop of York, on the Present Corrupt State of the Church of England. London, 1831.
23.
Zholudov M. V. Ideologiya i politika liberal'noi partii Velikobritanii v 30-e gody XIX veka. Ryazan', 1997.
24.
Tupoleva L. F. Dvizhenie za parlamentskuyu reformu 1832 g. v Anglii // Iz istorii evropeiskogo parlamentarizma. Velikobritaniya. M., 1995. S. 111–123.
25.
Simon W. G. The Bishops and Reform // Historical Magazine of the Protestant Episcopal Church. 1963. Vol. 32, № 4. P. 361–370.
26.
The Times. 29.09.1831.
27.
Stetskevich M. S. Parlamentskaya reforma 1832 g. i Tserkov' Anglii // Trudy kafedry istorii novogo i noveishego vremeni. 2014. №13. S. 59–72.
28.
The Times. 12.10.1831.
29.
The Times. 24.10.1831.
30.
The Times. 26.10.1831.
31.
The Times. 29.10.1831.
32.
The Times. 31.10.1831.
33.
London Courier and Evening Gazette. 15.10.1831.
34.
[Wade J.] The Black Book; Or, Corruption Unmasked! London, 1820.
35.
[Wade J.] The Extraordinary Black Book; or, Public Abuses Unveiled. London, 1831.
36.
[Wade J.] The Extraordinary Black Book; or, Public Abuses Unveiled. London, 1832.
37.
[Wade J.] Appendix to the Black Book. London, 1835.
38.
Henley R. A Plan of Church Reform. With a Letter to King. London, 1832.
39.
Hansard’s Parliamentary Debates. Third Series. Vol. 22.
40.
Hansard’s Parliamentary Debates. Third Series. Vol. 33.
41.
Hansard’s Parliamentary Debates. Third Series. Vol. 36.
42.
Lord’s Reform – the Lords Spiritual // [http://www.secularism.org.uk/uploads/religious-represenation-in-the-hose-of-lords-briefing-4.pdf, accessed on 01.03.2018].