Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 1863,   Articles in work: 316 Declined articles: 771 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

A Source-Study Analysis of Memoirs on the Defense of Sevastopol in 1854-1855: a Formulation of the Question
Shapovalova Natalia Vital'evna

Post-graduate student, the department of Source Studies, Moscow State University

119991, Russia, Moskva oblast', g. Moscow, ul. Lomonosovskii Prospekt, 27-4

shapovalovanv1993@gmail.com

 

 

Abstract.

The subject of this study is the Russian memoirs on the defense of Sevastopol in 1854-1855. This complex of sources is considered by the author as a single, historically developed body of work. The study serves to raise the question of the overall chronological parameters of the examined source complex. The article is focused on published memoirs, which the author discovered to be about 200 units. The given formulation of this problem requires special attention towards the socio-historiographic context on the background of which the memoir tradition developed, which the author carried out by analyzing how the historical memory concerning the defense of Sevastopol was formed. The methodological basis of this work is grounded on the principles of historicism and scientific objectivity, and the special methods: historical-typological, problem-chronological, and source-study analyses. The novelty of this study consists in it raising the question of conducting a source-study examination of memoirs on the defense of Sevastopol in 1854-1855. Considering these memoirs from the point of view of their own history as a single complex has allowed the author to write the development process of the memoir genre on this topic into the context of the evolution of the memoir genre in Russia in general. The conducted source-study analysis is the principal foundation for a deeper and more effective uncovering of the factual information embedded in memoires. This study outlines the promising vectors for further searches of memoir works.

Keywords: commemoration work, controversy, historical memory, social conscience, historical source, memoirs, Crimean war, the Siege of Sevastopol, the Russian Empire, source studies

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0609.2018.3.26214

Article was received:

13-05-2018


Review date:

09-05-2018


Publish date:

14-05-2018


This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Tarle E. V. Krymskaya voina: v 2 t. SPb.: Nauka, 2011. T. II. 509 s.
2.
Chennyk S. V. Krymskaya voina. Sevastopol', 2017. 400 s.
3.
Vinichenko M. V. Oborona Sevastopolya 1854-1855 gg. Nazemno-podzemnoe protivostoyanie. M.: Tseikhgauz, 2007. 48 s.
4.
Mel'nikova L. V. Russkaya Pravoslavnaya Tserkov' i Krymskaya voina 1853-1856 gg. M.: Kuchkovo pole, 2012. 392 s.
5.
Naumova Yu. A. Ranenie, bolezn' i smert': russkaya meditsinskaya sluzhba v Krymskuyu voinu 1853-1856 gg. M.: REGNUM, 2010. 320 s.
6.
Pavlenko O. V. Krymskaya voina v istoricheskoi pamyati Rossiiskoi imperii na rubezhe XIX-XX vv. //Vestnik RGGU. Seriya Politologiya. Istoriya. Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. Zarubezhnoe regionovedenie. Vostokovedenie. 2014. . 18 (140). S. 9-37.
7.
Fedotova M. S. Sevastopol'skaya oborona (1854-1855 gg.) v kul'turnoi pamyati dorevolyutsionnoi Rossii: diss. kand. ist. nauk. SPb., 2012. 316 s.
8.
Makarova S. E. Psikhologiya russkogo kharaktera na primere sobytii Krymskoi voiny 1853-1856 godov (po vospominaniyam N. V. Berga) // Aktual'nye voprosy obshchestvennykh nauk: sotsiologiya, politologiya, filosofiya, istoriya. 2015. 53. S. 33-42.
9.
Makarova S. E. Sostoyanie russkoi oborony Sevastopolya v fevrale-iyune 1855 goda (po vospominaniyam N. V. Berga) // Universum: obshchestvennye nauki. 2016. 1-4 (22). S. 1.
10.
Tartakovskii A. G. 1812 god i russkaya memuaristika. M.: Nauka, 1980. 312 s.
11.
Istoriya dorevolyutsionnoi Rossii v dnevnikakh i vospominaniyakh. M.: Kniga, 1980. T. 3. Ch. 2. 367 s.
12.
Nepomnyashchii A. A. Istoriya i etnografiya narodov Kryma: bibliografiya i arkhivy (konets XVIII nachalo XX veka. Simferopol': Dolya, 2001. 816 s.
13.
Registratsionnaya bibliografiya po istorii Sevastopolya i Chernomorskogo flota perioda Krymskoi (Vostochnoi) voiny. Sevastopol', 1966. 345 l.
14.
Zhandr A. P. Nekotorye podrobnosti o smerti vitse-admirala Kornilova // Morskoi sbornik. 1854. 12. S. 440-443.
15.
Popov A. A. Eshche podrobnosti o smerti general-ad''yutanta Kornilova // Morskoi sbornik. 1854. 12. S. 443-473.
16.
Kedrina L. Iz moikh vospominanii // Russkii Arkhiv. 1917. 1. S. 102-135.
17.
Professor khirurgii Kh. Ya. Gyubbenet i ego vospominaniya ob oborone Sevastopolya // Russkaya Starina. 1889. T. 61. 1. S. 75-99.
18.
Obninskii N. A. Zapiski o Krymskom pokhode 1855-1856 godov // Russkii Arkhiv. 1891. Kn. 3. 11. S. 330-412.
19.
Narochnitskaya L. I. Rossiya i otmena neitralizatsii Chernogo morya. 1856-1871 gg. M.: Nauka, 1989. 222 s.
20.
Boldyrev A. V. Russko-turetskie otnosheniya serediny 19 v. i rossiiskoe obshchestvo. M.: Izdatel'stvo MBA, 2013. 496 s.
21.
Evgenov P. Moi vospominaniya o Sevastopol'skoi oborone i o darovanii krest'yanam svobody. M.: tip. I.I. Radzevicha, 1898. 40 s.
22.
Tatishchev S. S. Vneshnyaya politika imperatora Nikolaya Pervogo. Vvedenie v istoriyu vneshnikh snoshenii Rossii v epokhu sevastopol'skoi voiny. SPb.: tip. I. N. Skorokhodova, 1887. 639 s.
23.
Krasovskii I. I. Boi pri reke Chernoi, 4-go avgusta 1855 g. // Russkaya starina. 1876. 10. S. 363-364.
24.
Bassau A. Otvet na otzyv o pokoinom moem muzhe, ubitom na Malakhovom kurgane // Morskoi sbornik. 1863. 5. Prilozh., S. 2-4.
25.
Sevastopolets. Zametka na stat'yu Vospominaniya na Krymskom poluostrove v 1854 i 1855 gg. // Voennyi sbornik. 1874. 6. S. 396.
26.
Ryzhov I. I. O srazhenii pod Balaklavoi. Zapiski // Russkii Vestnik. 1870. T. 86. 4. S. 463-469.
27.
Kozhukhov S. D. Neskol'ko slov po povodu zapiski general-leitenanta Ryzhova o Balaklavskom srazhenii // Russkii Arkhiv. 1870. S. 1668-1676.
28.
Golovachev V. F. Vospominaniya po povodu 50-letnego yubileya Sinopskogo srazheniya // Morskoi sbornik. 1903. 11. S. 53-61.
29.
Iz zapisok sevastopol'tsa // Russkii Arkhiv. 1867. 12. Stb. 1579-1637.
30.
Zhandr A. P. Materialy dlya istorii oborony Sevastopolya i biografiya V. A. Kornilova. SPb., 1859. 396 s.
31.
Kronshtadtskii vestnik. 1868. 8. 21 yanvarya.
32.
Krashennikov S. Zamechaniya na stat'yu Iz zapisok sevastopol'tsa, pomeshchennuyu v 12 Russkogo arkhiva. 1867 g. // Morskoi Sbornik. 1868. 2.
33.
Kirpichev Yu. Oshibki admirala Kornilova. URL: http://lebed.com/2012/art6062.htm (provereno: 12.04.18.).
34.
Afanas'ev. Otvet moryaka Russkomu arkhivu // Kronshtadtskii vestnik. 1868. 31 yanvarya.
35.
Narbut F. Po povodu stat'i Iz zapsiok sevastopol'tsa, pomeshchennoi v Russkom arkhive 12 1867 g. // Morskoi sbornik. 1868. 4. Bibliografiya. S. 28.
36.
Alabin P.V. Sevastopol'skii muzei // Russkii invalid. 1869. 1. 2 yanvarya.
37.
Po povodu stat'i "Sevastopol'skii muzei" // Russkii Invalid. 1869. 22. 20 fevralya.
38.
Pravitel'stvennyi vestnik. 1870. 221. 16 oktyabrya.
39.
Miloshevich N.S. Iz zapisok sevastopol'tsa. SPb., 1904.
40.
Alekseev P. V. Vospominaniya o Krymskoi voine. RGALI. F. 1337. Op. 1. Ed. khr. 3.
41.
Kachenovskii V. Sevastopol'skii otdel // Vestnik Moskovskoi politekhnicheskoi vystavki. 1872. 60. 29 iyunya.
42.
Dubrovin N.F. Materialy dlya istorii Krymskoi voiny i oborony Sevastopolya: v 5 kn. SPb.: Tip. Tip. departamenta udelov, 1871. Kn. 1. S. XI.
43.
[Delo kantselyarii imperatorskogo dvora o prazdnovanii 50-letiya sevastopol'skoi oborony]. RGIA. F. 472. Op. 45. D. 55.
44.
Amfiteatrov A.V. Port-Artur i Sevastopol' // Kurgany. SPb., 1906. S. 258-264.
45.
Rol' flota v 1854 godu i teper' // Novoe vremya. 1904. 16 maya.
46.
Zapiski K.D Khlebnikova // Russkii arkhiv, 1907. 3-6.
47.
Opisanie oborony g. Sevastopolya. SPb.: tip. Tiblena, 1863-1872.
48.
Avramov N. Pamyatka veterana sevastopol'tsa i ego potomkov. SPb.: Ofitser-vospitatel', 1907. 146 s.
49.
Petropavlovskii V. Nezabyvaemye mgnoveniya. Sevastopol', 1995. 65 s