Рус Eng During last 365 days Approved articles: 1912,   Articles in work: 306 Declined articles: 803 
Library
Articles and journals | Tariffs | Payments | Your profile

Back to contents

Evolution of approaches to the problem of Other/Alien: from philosophical comprehension to the phenomenon of Other/Alien as an object of historical-culturological discourse
Aliev Rastyam Tuktarovich

PhD in History

senior researcher at Astrakhan State University

414056, Russia, Astrakhan', Tatishchev's str., 20a, room No. 412

rastaliev@gmail.com
Другие публикации этого автора
 

 
Avtorkhanova Dagmara Movsarovna

Post-graduate student, the department of Culturology, Astrakhan State University

414056, Russia, Astrakhanskaya oblast', g. Astrakhan', ul. Tatishcheva, 20 A

adagmara@yandex.ru

Abstract.

This article is dedicated to the examination of evolution of the theoretical-methodological approaches towards comprehension of the phenomenon of Other/Alien as an object of historical-culturological discourse. The authors hold the view that initially the phenomenon of otherness was a subject of philosophical comprehension, but with the development of scientific thought, technologies and mediatization of the modern society, the problem of Other/Alien acquires a qualitatively new characteristic. The interest to the phenomenon of Other/Alien is not coincidental, as its defined primarily due to the escalated attention from mass media, journalism, literature, politics and other spheres of social life. However the key problem at that level is the method of labeling of Other/Alien. This article represents a continuation of the studies on evolution of the theoretical-methodological approaches to the problem of Other/Alien. The previous worked has already dicussed the interest of the ancient authors, medieval theologians, and thinkers of the Age of Enlightenment of Modern History to this problem, as well as the philosophes of such disciplines as phenomenology (E. Husserl), ethical philosophy (E. Levinas), existentialism (J-P. Sartre). In the current article, the authors reveal the approaches to the problem of Other/Alien in the works of M. M. Bakhtin, B. Waldenfels, P. Ricœurl; postmodernists J. Derrida, G. Deleuze, F. Guattari; structural psychoanalyst J. Lacan; theoretician of orientalism E. Said; and other post-colonialists, supporters of small groups (SubAltern Studies), Russian culturologists and historians.

Keywords: Vision, Body without organs, SubAltern Studies, Structural psychoanalysis, Postcolonialism, Postmodernism, Alien, Other, Orientalism, Otherness

DOI:

10.7256/2454-0757.2018.6.26571

Article was received:

14-06-2018


Review date:

12-06-2018


Publish date:

16-06-2018


This article written in Russian. You can find full text of article in Russian here .

References
1.
Gallaher S. Key Concepts in Political Geography. – SAGE Publications, 2009. – 392 p.
2.
Gregory D., Johnston R., Pratt G., Watts M., Whatmore S. The Dictionary of Human Geography. – John Wiley & Sons, 2011. – 1052 p.
3.
Lacan J. Ecrits I. – Ed. Du Seuil, 1966. – 911 p.
4.
Lacan J. Ecrits. – Paris: Seuil, 1966. – 912 p.
5.
Miller J.-A. The Seminar of Jacques Lacan: Book I. – Cambridge, 1988. – 320 p.
6.
Miller J.-A. The Seminar of Jacques Lacan: Book II. – Cambridge, 1988. – 311 p.
7.
Rieder J. Colonialism and the Emergence of Science Fiction. – Wesleyan University Press, 2012. – 450 p.
8.
Avtonomova N.S. Poznanie i perevod. Opyty filosofii yazyka. – M.: Rossiiskaya politicheskaya entsiklopediya (ROSSPEN), 2008. – 704 s.
9.
Buber M. Ya i Ty. – Vysshaya shkola, 1993. – 175 s.
10.
Val'denfel's B. Motiv chuzhogo. – Minsk, 1999. – 176 s.
11.
Delez, Zh., Gvattari, F., Anti-Edip. Kapitalizm i Shizofreniya. – U-Faktoriya, 2007. – 672 s.
12.
Derrida Zh. O grammatologii. – M.: Ad Marginem. 2000. – 506 s.
13.
Derrida Zh. Slukhobiografii: Uchenie Nitsshe i politika imeni sobstvennogo. – SPb.: Machina, 2012. – 116 s.
14.
D'yakov A. V. Zhak Lakan. Figura filosofa. – M.: Izdatel'skii dom «Territoriya budushchego», 2010. – 560 s.
15.
Zhak Lakan. Elektronnaya biblioteka Instituta filosofii RAN. — [Elektronnyi resurs] — URL : https://iphlib.ru/greenstone3/library/collection/newphilenc/document/HASH131b8ed3772dfc457f4613
16.
Kant I. Prolegomeny ko vsyakoi budushchei metafizike, mogushchei poyavit'sya kak nauka. – M.: Mysl', 1965. – 320 s.
17.
Kolesnikov A.S., Stavtsev S.N., Formy sub''ektivnosti v filosofskoi kul'ture XX veka. – SPb.: Sankt-Peterburgskoe filosofskoe obshchestvo, 2000. – 112 s.
18.
Lakan Zh. Instantsiya bukvy v bessoznatel'nom (sbornik). – M.: «Russkoe fenomenologicheskoe obshchestvo», 1997. – 184 s.
19.
Lakan Zh. Seminary. Kniga 5: Obrazovaniya bessoznatel'nogo (1957/58). – M.: Gnozis/Logos, 2002. – 608 s.
20.
Pakholova I. V. Opyt «Chuzhogo» v terminakh intentsional'nosti i responzivnosti (E. Gusserl', B. Vandel'fel's) // Vestnik SamGU. 2006. – №5/1 (45). – S. 22-27.
21.
Pigalev A.I. R. Zhirar i M. Khaidegger: o smysle «preodoleniya metafiziki» // Voprosy filosofii. – 2001 –. №9 (10). – S. 152-169.
22.
Podoroga V. A. Slovar' analiticheskoi antropologii // Logos. – 1999. – №2. – 20-28
23.
Podoroga V. Fenomenologiya tela. Vvedenie v filosofskuyu antropologiyu – M.: Ad Marginem, 1995. — 340 s.
24.
Postmodernizm: Entsiklopediya / pod red. A. A. Gritsanova. M. A. Mozheiko. – Interpresservis, 2001. – 1038 s.
25.
Riker P. Ya – sam kak Drugoi. – M.: Izdatel'stvo gumanitarnoi literatury, 2008. – 416 s.
26.
Romanova A. P., Khlyshcheva E. V., Yakushenkov S. N., Topchiev M. S. Chuzhoi i kul'turnaya bezopasnost'. – Moskva, 2013. – 215 s.
27.
Romanova A.P., Yakushenkov S.N., Khlyshcheva E.V., Kanat'eva N. S., Yakushenkova O.S., Topchiev M.S., Aliev R.T., Dzhenenko O.V., Sarakaeva E.A., Zolotykh L.G., Morozova E.V. Mnogolikii Drugoi. Invariantnost' obrazov Drugogo/Chuzhogo: kollektivnaya monografiya. – Astrakhan': Izdatel': Sorokin Roman Vasil'evich, 2018. – 334 s.
28.
Said E. Orientalizm. Zapadnaya kontseptsiya Vostoka. – SPb: Russkii Mir'', 2006. – 637 s.
29.
Fuko M. Istoriya bezumiya v klassicheskuyu epokhu. – M.: LST: LST Moskva, 2010. – 698 s.
30.
Yakushenkov S.N. Yakushenkova O.S. Telo Varvara: konstruirovanie obraza chuzhogo na kitaiskom frontire // Kaspiiskii region: politika, ekonomika, kul'tura. – 2012. – № 4. – S. 234–241